Sea to Sky Law Blog

DEFAMATION versus FAIR COMMENT

Posted by Andrew Liggett | Aug 27, 2023 | 0 Comments

DEFAMATION versus FAIR COMMENT

The recent decision of Hansman v. Neufeld, 2023 SCC 14 by our Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) on 19 May 2023 is a good example of the balancing of interests in our "free" society where we expect to have individual freedom of speech but there also has to be a balance with the protection of public interests (eg do not shout fire in a crowded theatre) nor can you defame someone by harming their reputation.

This SCC case is a good example of the analysis required to balance the need to protect the individual ability to make a "fair comment" with the need to protect against defamation of personal reputation especially in the internet age. This SCC decision was a consideration of the 2019 British Columbia Protection of Public Participation Act (“PPPA”) which allows the Court to dismiss a defamation claim before there is a trial on the merits, saving a lot of legal expense, if the stipulated factors are met by the Defendant applying to have the Claim dismissed - even if some harm had been caused to the Claimant's reputation by the Defendant's comments.

The PPPA helps protect the public interest of having a public discourse about important topics by stopping defamation claims which could be a strategic lawsuit against public participation (“SLAPP”). As many of us now know from the Trump era, some individuals try to stomp on "fair comment" by suing which naturally scares individuals from speaking up. Our SCC protected our ability to "speak truth to power".

About the Author

Andrew Liggett

Mr. Andrew Liggett, BA JD CD, Esquire Our Firm Founder Andrew has decades of successful experience representing clients throughout British Columbia in all levels of court including the Provincial Court, the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal. Andrew completed a Bachelor's Degree in Political...

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Contact Us Today

Sea to Sky Law Group is committed to answering your questions about, Estate, Business, Mediation, and Dispute Resolution issues in British Columbia. We offer experienced advice to support your DIY self-representation efforts or by a full-service traditional retainer. We can discuss your case and help you develop a solution plan by phone or in-person or virtually eg by Zoom. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.

Menu